The aftermath of 'Cha'

At 26 James 'Cha' Fitzpatrick has decided to hang up his intercounty helmet in what could be described as a shock to many. Having won five senior inter-county All Ireland titles as well as three All Stars, the Kilkenny hurler has cited lack of game time as the main reason for his decision.

Playing senior intercounty hurling or football is a massive committment for any team and no more so than for a group that can be described as the most successful hurling team to ever compete. Fitzpatrick is a teacher in Dublin and travelling to Kilkenny for training more than likely adds to his efforts. Failing to nail down a starting place only adds to the strain.

The papers carried the story from early in the week of the retirement but beyond that there seemed to be an agenda. It was mooted that Fitzpatrick could declare for Dublin. There seemed to be little fact behind the possibility yet the media seemed to welcome it as a positive switch. Why? Probably because there is a school of thought that Dublin hurling needs to be strong to keep hurling both interesting and competitive? And what better way to promote hurling in Dublin as well as increasing the potential of the senior team than to bring in a player of Cha's reputation and quality.

This is the first time I have read reports of transfer within the GAA as positive. If Fitzpatrick wanted to join Tipperary, would it be viewed as a positive move or as a threat to the amateur ethos and the intercounty structure we have in place? I doubt the GAA would encourage such a move. The media would print articles of how a player sold out and brand the GAA as 'in crisis' with fears of more intercounty transfers.

In today's (23/11/11) Irish Independent, Martin Breheny suggests that Fitzpatrick is destined to declare for Dublin. The player listed 'The Moon' as a location he would like to holiday, the home of the Sea of Tranquility. Breheny asks, 'how's this for a coincidence? The geological description of the Sea of Tranquility notes that "whenever colour is processed and extracted from multiple photographs, it gives off a slightly bluish shade". Surely a sign that 'Cha' is destined to end up with Dublin. It's written in the stars, or at least on the Moon'.

There's no doubt that this is tongue and cheek from the reporter but it gauges the ease with which the media are willing to marry 'Cha' and Dublin hurling. As a player who has relocated in Dublin and switched to a Dublin club I know there is an unease regarding the amount of players joining clubs in the capital. It would seem that the proposed intercounty transfer of a high profile player should cause massive debate but it appears to be accepted if not welcomed!

The media shape opinions on wide reaching subjects from current affairs to fashion to sport. If the media decided to suggest that a possible switch from Kilkenny to Dublin was an outrage, then that would be the talking point. It seems though that the media have now championed the Cha to Dublin cause and opened the public's mind to the prospect. Now, I don't believe that a player who has achieved all that he has with his native Kilkenny would be interested in a move to play with Dublin, but maybe I'm wrong.

What would happen if a move went ahead? We already have rumours of Cavan's Seanie Johnston and Offaly's Niall McNamee joining Kildare. Does this signal the end of the current intercounty structure? I'll nail my flag to the mast here, if I could get paid to play GAA I would grab it with both hands, who wouldn't? At the same time, playing for your county is a fantastic reward and brings great pride. However, the modern game is so demanding that it is increasingly harder to give the required committment while balancing work, family and everything else. Either way, I don't see it as a cross roads we will reach during my playing time but eventually the debate will need to be settled.

Once that happens, the media will be at the forefront of the discussion and be under no illusions; their view will play a major role in the outcome.